The Activity That Fails

Activity Download

Download lesson outline and handouts (Microsoft Word)

Optional cartoons

This brief classroom activity can be used to informally assess students’ ability to apply the principles of economic reasoning to environmental issues.

Time: ½ – 1 class period


  • Handout: “Check Your Environmental Reasoning” – 1 per student (pp. 4-6)
  • Overhead Transparencies:
    • “Consensus-Building Through Discussion” (p. 3)
    • “Tally” (p. 7)
    • (Optional) Cartoons (pp. 8-13)


  1. Distribute “Check Your Environmental Reasoning” and have students enter their answers in the blanks on the last page without consulting one another.
  2. Have students place their answer-sheets face down when completed. Prepare for the next part of the activity by reviewing the process of consensus-building. Use the Hayakawa quote (see overhead transparency, p. 2) to emphasize that consensus-building discussions depend on active and open-minded listening; that the goal is to come to a common understanding rather than to hold firmly to a particular position or brow-beat others into agreement.
  3. Direct students to choose partners, compare answers, discuss, and reach consensus.
  4. Direct partner teams to combine into groups of 4. Allow time for partner teams to compare answers, discuss, and reach consensus.
  5. (Optional) Continue the consensus process with larger and larger groups.
  6. Reconvene the class and allow groups to report on their conclusions. Expect disagreement. One way to manage the debriefing is to tally the cartoon votes for each statement, and then ask for representatives from various groups to explain their reasoning.

Teacher Guide:

The artist drew the cartoons to match specific statements. However, field test groups consistently failed to come up with the same answers as the artist – or with the same answers as other field test groups. (Hence, the title of the activity.)

A careful review of the cartoons reveals that there are, in fact, several sets of arguably correct answers. The key to assessing students’ mastery with this activity lies in determining whether they are able to clearly articulate the reasons for assigning a particular cartoon to a statement. Their reasoning should reflect accurate knowledge of the economic concepts and accurate application of the economic principles to the situation as they interpret it from the cartoon.

Debbie Henney, FTE Director of Curriculum Receives Bessie B Moore Service Award

  Foundation for Teaching Economics is proud to announce that Debbie Henney, director of curriculum for the Foundation for Teaching…

FTE Pays Tribute to Jerry Hume

It is with deep sadness that we announce the loss of William J. Hume, known as Jerry Hume, former Chairman…

Why We Should Be Teaching Students Economic Literacy

Ted Tucker, Executive Director, Foundation for Teaching Economics October 26, 2022 More high schools are offering courses on personal finance…